DFW Multifamily Property Directory
Menu

Carlisle on the Katy Trail

Updated 2026-08-13 · 4,321 reviewed · 600 listed · How we rank ›

No rating yet 39 composite score See reviews on Google ✓ Google-verified
Luxury High-Rise ApartmentsAffordable & Income Restricted Housing
Carlisle on the Katy Trail
Services
Luxury High-Rise Apartments, Affordable & Income Restricted Housing

What we found

Most recent reviewers praise the location, cleanliness, and leasing staff expertise, especially Quay and Karen's application support. A significant one-star review details chronic maintenance failures: incomplete repairs, problems recurring within days, and new damage caused during fixes, with management deflecting blame to the building's age rather than addressing systemic issues.

Recent shift: Sharp contrast between recent 5-star leasing and location reviews versus one detailed 2-month-old complaint about chronic maintenance issues; new management team mentioned in early reviews may signal change, but maintenance pattern concern persists in that 1-star account.

Praised for
  • responsive maintenance (some tenants)
  • friendly leasing staff
  • great location near Katy Trail and restaurants
  • clean grounds and solid amenities
Watch-outs
  • incomplete repairs and bandaid solutions
  • maintenance mistakes create new problems
  • follow-up work met with resentment
  • unresolved issues blamed on building age
friendly-staffclean-groundsmodern-amenitiesmaintenance-slowmaintenance-quick
Best for: Professionals seeking Uptown proximity and walkable lifestyle; long-term residents familiar with maintenance patterns.
Think twice if: Renters who rely on quick maintenance fixes or cannot tolerate incomplete work and repeated service visits.

What's working here

  • Walking distance to Katy Trail, West Village, and dining
  • responsive leasing process (weeks to move-in)
  • established community (multi-year residents)

Read this before you tour

  • Quay and Karen provide leasing tours and application support
  • Stephanie on maintenance team praised for responsiveness (by some reviewers)
  • Some tenants report 4-year residency with no plans to leave
  • One reviewer documented pattern of incomplete repairs recalling within days to minutes

Side by side with nearby options

Why this score

How We Score
Star rating 0
Review volume 0
Review recency 100
Review sentiment 48
Profile completeness 100
Verification 30

Contact the property

Address
3140 N Hall St, Dallas, TX 75204

Last verified 2026-08-13

When the office is open

Monday
08:30-17:30
Tuesday
08:30-17:30
Wednesday
08:30-17:30
Thursday
08:30-17:30
Friday
08:30-17:30
Saturday
Closed
Sunday
Closed

As listed on Google.

In their own words

Services listed
Studio apartmentsOne-bedroom apartmentsTwo-bedroom apartmentsThree-bedroom apartmentsTwo poolsFitness centerGated parking

As published by the business on its own website; not independently verified.

Enquire about Carlisle on the Katy Trail

Your enquiry goes to the DFW Multifamily Property Directory team, who will pass it to Carlisle on the Katy Trail. We only share your details with providers relevant to your request.

Similar apartment complexes nearby

MAA Katy Trail
68

MAA Katy Trail

4.0(204)✓ Google-verifiedPublishes prices

Residents love the location, unit quality, and maintenance team's quick response to apartment issues. However, chronic elevator failures, weak building security, and a dysfunctional mailroom undermine the luxury positioning, with management prioritizing cosmetic updates over critical repairs.

Luxury High-Rise Apartments
MAA North Hall
64

MAA North Hall

3.8(143)✓ Google-verifiedPublishes prices

Strong maintenance staff (Peter, Edward, Stephanie) earn consistent praise for fast, professional work and smooth move-ins. However, serious structural and operational issues persist: broken security gates enable theft, elevators fail regularly, poor insulation creates noise and pest entry, and unresponsive management ignores complaints despite three-month notice requirements and unexpected fees.

Luxury High-Rise Apartments
Whitney Uptown
55

Whitney Uptown

3.0(203)✓ Google-verified

Tour and move-in staff like Michael, Aurelio, and Tiffany earn consistent praise for warmth and professionalism, and the Uptown location is described as prime. Behind the leasing desk, the experience fractures: elevators malfunction for weeks at a time, AC breaks are unresolved for 40+ days, mold concerns are dismissed, and management becomes unreachable once a lease is signed. Recent cases show locked residents, police calls, and wrongly withheld security deposits. Staff turnover and inconsistent accountability leave those who need help unable to reach anyone by phone or in person. Brayan and Michael emerged as exceptions who tried to help, but they could not offset systemic gaps in maintenance scheduling, elevator upkeep, communication protocols, and leadership follow-through. One resident documented over a year of repeated failures: floods, electrical outages, broken appliances, and a missing window in a unit offered as move-in ready. The building's image polished for tours collapses once occupancy begins.

Luxury High-Rise Apartments

Own this business? Get featured

Own or market a business here? Ask about featured placement and advertising on this directory. Your message goes straight to the directory team.

Last updated 2026-08-13